AI answers shifted within a day: 84% of 210 buying questions changed
A team asked four AI engines the same 210 buying questions on two days in a row and compared the answers. The result was striking: 84% of responses had changed within a single day. Checking once whether a brand shows up in AI answers, then, says very little.
According to the report, the mechanism is simple: an AI answer is not a fixed ranking but a summary of a handful of pages the engine read at that moment. In one example, a CRM question put to Google AI Mode surfaced one brand first on day one, then dropped it entirely the next day in favor of another. The brands had not changed; the pages the engine read had.
The article notes differences between engines too. Gemini was the most volatile, with its brand list changing on 95% of questions the next day. ChatGPT stayed most loyal to its first pick. Category leaders also held their ground better, keeping 73% of their spots versus 51% for brands that appear less often. According to the report, that is because leaders sit on most of the pages AI reads.
Why does this matter to readers? Anyone who turns to AI when researching a product may get a different answer tomorrow. For brands, the takeaway is to ask the same questions repeatedly and track how often they appear rather than relying on a single screenshot. The article notes that one answer named about six brands on average, while eight answers to the same question surfaced 14 different brands in total.