All stories
Internet

Amazon's Deal Problem: A Third of 'Best' Offers Had No Savings

Amazon's Deal Problem: A Third of 'Best' Offers Had No Savings

Many products Amazon promoted as the 'best' deals during Black Friday and Cyber Monday may not have delivered the savings shoppers expected. According to an investigation by Groundwork Collaborative titled 'Deal or Decoy?', nearly one in three of these featured offers were priced the same as, or lower than, the month before the sale.

The report examined prices for more than 350 products listed on Amazon's own deal pages for the 2024 and 2025 Black Friday and Cyber Monday events, according to the report. Those pages present the discounts as some of the year's top bargains. The findings show that about one in ten products advertised as deals were actually more expensive during the sale than in the month leading up to it.

The report notes that Amazon's 2025 Black Friday page describes its offers as 'handpicked' selections of the best deals available. Its authors, Breyon Williams, Elizabeth Pancotti and Lindsay Owens, frame the results as a gap between how deals are marketed and what shoppers actually pay. Lindsay Owens, president and CEO of Groundwork Collaborative, said shoppers wait all year for these events and trust that advertised deals mean real savings, but argued that the major sales are not all they are made out to be and that lawmakers should hold the company accountable if it cannot deliver on that promise.

The issue goes beyond a single product's price: an internet 'deal' label does not guarantee the price has actually dropped. According to the report, the findings underscore the value of checking a product's price history before a sale, since a campaign price can be higher than what the item cost just weeks earlier.